It turns out that a heavily cited safety stat that Tesla received from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) back in 2017 isn't so accurate based on Sister Emanuellefindings from a research group that got their hands on Tesla crash data.
Following a deadly Tesla crash involving Autopilot, Tesla's semi-autonomous advanced driver assistance system, a 2017 federal report found that Autopilot led to a 40 percent crash reduction. But last week a small research group finally obtained most of the data NHTSA used to reach that number and found the underlying data was severely flawed.
SEE ALSO: Groom credits Tesla Model X for saving his life the night before his own weddingThe discovery confirms what the group, Quality Control Systems Corp., and others like this report from Wiredlast May suspected. People had been skeptical of the data for a long time. Even NHTSA said last year the numbers weren't as solid as they had originally indicated. The QCS researchers wrote in their report, "Remarkably, NHTSA’s announcement was not accompanied by any of the data underlying this astonishing claim." So back in 2017 they requested the data and successfully fought for access.
Autopilot software and hardware has changed since the report came out, so this doesn't have much bearing on how Tesla cars function now. Tesla continues to earn high marks in crash safety tests. It's also been years since that data was collected. Tesla's since hit 1 billion miles on Autopilot. The number of Tesla vehicles on the road has ballooned in the past few years.
But now, measuring claims of increased safety on Autopilot and using features like Autosteer that keep the car in the lane isn't as clear-cut. QCS has shown that NHTSA made crash rate calculations using a Tesla data set with missing data and other flaws.
Ars Technica delves further into the math and problems calculating the crash rate if you want to understand the denominators and mileage calculations. The publication also points out other factors affecting safety, like Tesla driver age and socioeconomic status.
Tesla does voluntarily put out its own safety reports -- though those are pretty brief.
UPDATE: Feb. 13, 2019, 6:42 p.m. PST Tesla said in a statement about the QCS report that "given the dramatic increase in the number of Tesla vehicles on the road, their analysis today represents about 0.5% of the total mileage that Tesla vehicles have traveled to date, and about 1% of the total mileage that Tesla vehicles have traveled to date with Autopilot engaged." QCS focused on NHTSA data from only 5,714 vehicles.
A Tesla spokesperson also added that Tesla's own data analysis from 2 billion miles "shows that drivers using Autopilot were significantly less likely to be involved in an accident than those driving without using Autopilot.” Last quarter, Tesla found with Autopilot on drivers experienced one incident for every 2.91 million miles compared to those without Autopilot every 1.58 million miles.
Topics Tesla
Previous：You Know You Want It
A Show Trial that No One Watched
CBS fires Charlie Rose following sexual misconduct allegations
Al Franken's female 'SNL' colleagues write open letter defending him
Google announces a fix for the Pixel 2 buzzing noise
The Reaching-Out Industry
Angry 'Justice League' fans petition for Zack Snyder's cut
This adorable Google Doodle is an ode to kimchi
This may be the most spectacular car parking fail of all time
#churchtoo
Researchers show that water didn't carve these dark flows on Mars
Best headphones deal: Save $120 on Sony WH
Electric scooter folds down into a block you can put under your arm
Adorable Tesla phone charger is perfect for your desk
Funko has created a pretty adorable version of 'Stranger Things' Dart
Élite Politesse
Samsung's flexible Galaxy X could launch in January 2018, report says
Woman removed by security for 'dancing' at a Stevie Nicks concert
Angry tweets pour in after Trump ends protected status for Haitians
The Complacent Intellectual Class
Enter your tech product for Mashable's 'Top Picks of CES 2018'
Your internet provider is full of it on net neutrality. Now with proof.All of the 'Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt: Kimmy vs. The Reverend' endingsPeople are freaking out about the eyebrow wigs need to know what thisEven the White House doesn't know what Ivanka Trump doesAmazon's proposed federal antiElon Musk said he wants to sell all of his homes. 5 just hit the market for $95.5 million.Latest Google Chrome update lets users sort tabs by groups and colorsLiv Little on galHeadspace is now free for unemployed AmericansTaylor Swift's alleged new boyfriend isn't even verified on Twitter yetTwitter says new coronavirus misinformation rules will apply to TrumpStudent describes the ‘90s as 'the late 1900s' and now we all feel oldAn iPad mini with a larger display might be coming and I'm very excitedAmazon launches faster Fire HD 8 tablets with more storageHouseparty's inMicrosoft rolls out protection against 'reply all' email stormsAn iPad mini with a larger display might be coming and I'm very excitedSenate gives law enforcement the OK to spy on your internet historyRIP Google Play Music: Users told to migrate to YouTube MusicTikTok faces scrutiny over minors' user data ... again FTC's 'Click to Cancel' ruling allows easier subscription cancellation X deemed not important enough to face EU antitrust regulations Amazon accidentally unveils Colorsoft, the first color Kindle Arkadium mini crossword answers for October 16 Best space heater deal: Save up to 36% on Dyson, Vornado, Honeywell models, and more Best star projector deal: Save 20% at Amazon Best gaming headset deal: Save $20 on Gtheos Gaming Headset Today's Hurdle hints and answers for October 16 Best Amazon deals of the day: Samsung Galaxy Watch 6, Galaxy Ring, AeroGarden Harvest, and more Watch Olivia Rodrigo fall through a hole in the stage mid Google's Android 15 is here, and it's all about security and privacy Samsung Freestyle projector deal: Get $200 off at Best Buy Elon Musk didn't invent fake tech demos Shop Beats headphones and speakers up to 55% off at Amazon Why is TikTok obsessed with the winter arc? Best poseable skeleton deals: Spook up your space with poseable skeleton deals Surfshark launches Data Leak Checker tool The best robot vacuum deals to shop post Prime Day Google is going nuclear for AI From Ian to Helene to Milton: Extreme weather is anything but 'natural'
2.3019s , 10130.6484375 kb
Copyright © 2025 Powered by 【Sister Emanuelle】,Information Information Network