Facebook isn't supposed to let advertisers target by things like age or Beauty Salon Special Service 4gender for employment ads anymore, but a new study showed that the social network's ad algorithm is doing it anyway.
More than two years after Facebook disabled that particular feature for housing and employment listings, researchers at the University of Southern California found that certain job listings mysteriously still show a noticeable skew in who sees them. The study's findings would be illegal under federal employment discrimination law.
"Our system takes into account many signals to try and serve people ads they will be most interested in, but we understand the concerns raised in the report," a Facebook spokesperson said in a statement responding to the study, shared with Mashable. "We’ve taken meaningful steps to address issues of discrimination in ads and have teams working on ads fairness today. We're continuing to work closely with the civil rights community, regulators, and academics on these important matters."
To understand the study, one must first understand an interesting carve-out in Title VII, the U.S. law that prohibits employment discrimination on the basis of race, gender, and so on. Employers are still technically allowed to hire based on "bona fide occupational qualifications." That means a company that makes men's clothing is legally allowed to only consider men for modeling positions, when that would be discrimination in most other fields.
While previous studies that reached the same conclusion about Facebook's ad algorithms used different methodology, the USC study focused on this by creating job listings for jobs that exhibit real-life gender demographic skews despite no real difference in qualifications. For example, Domino's Pizza delivery drivers are overwhelmingly male while Instacart grocery deliverers are predominantly female, per the study.
When the researchers created job listings for Domino's drivers and Instacart shoppers and ran them at the same time to the same audiences, the former were largely delivered to men and the latter to women by Facebook's backend advertising technology.
SEE ALSO: How to check if hackers are sharing your Facebook dataThis held true even with listings for software engineer and retail sales associate jobs that also carry the same real-life gender skew. Even when choosing to optimize the ad campaign for the most possible views (as opposed to the most likely click-throughs, another option Facebook offers advertisers), the gender gap still persisted. Interestingly, none of this happened when the same methodology was applied to LinkedIn's listing service.
We've known for years that Facebook's job ads technology allows for direct or indirect discrimination like this, but the fact that it still happens like this without human intervention years after Facebook promised to do better is concerning. Finding good work is difficult enough without some faceless algorithm keeping job listings away from you on the basis of your identity.
Topics Facebook Gender
Ireland fines TikTok $600 million for sharing user data with China
Hooker’s Green: The Color of Apple Trees and Envy by Katy Kelleher
Ms. Lucy's Steamboat by Jason Novak
Redux: The Wind Flakes Gold
NYT Connections hints and answers for May 18: Tips to solve 'Connections' #707.
Is Literature Dead? by David L. Ulin
Cracked Fairy Tales and the Holocaust by Sabrina Orah Mark
Five Young Women With Prize
Today's Hurdle hints and answers for May 5, 2025
Poetry Rx: Poor Deluded Human, You Seek My Heart
Bomb Envy
Pray Like Aretha Franklin by Michael Robbins
Leonor Fini: Theatre of Desire by The Paris Review
America Doesn’t Have to Be Like This
Ireland fines TikTok $600 million for sharing user data with China
From the Perspective of the Adoptee: An Interview with Nicole Chung
Redux: V. S. Naipaul by The Paris Review
Beyond Hygge: An Interview with Dorthe Nors by Alexandra Pereira
This is the fattest of the extremely fat bears
Becoming Kathy Acker: An Interview with Olivia Laing
Forget TSA PreCheck. Celebrities now have their own terminal at LAX.Twitter will soon have ads like Snapchat, within MomentsWe, your child's school, regret banning fidget spinners after seeing what toy came nextThe planning behind Fyre Festival, broken down by the numbersCarrie Fisher's daughter posts a touching tribute on Star Wars DaySpread love, ditch the nipple pasties: Miley Cyrus thinks about politics out loudOnePlus 5 confirmed to launch this summerBrave Americans to Congress: 'I am a pre'Dota 2' is adding a storyGovernment Twitter accounts are debating 'Star Wars' politics and it's greatForget TSA PreCheck. Celebrities now have their own terminal at LAX.This 'destroyed' pair of sneakers will run you $1,425Behold Crayola's new, thoroughly underwhelming crayonThere's a massive 'It' Easter egg hiding in 'The Dark Tower' trailerI insist on owning my music, even in the age of streamingDiscover what your name would be if you were a Kentucky Derby racehorseDelta apologizes after threatening parents with jail time over a seat they purchasedDarth Vader has found work as a hospital technicianCouple sitting on a boat created a very NSFW optical illusionThe planning behind Fyre Festival, broken down by the numbers Mozilla will record your voice for the next generation of voice apps Kids narrate the tough parts of growing up in cheeky animated videos A black 'Doctor Who' is long overdue too, says former Doctor Hackers stole $85 million in Ether to save it from *the real crooks Snapchat no longer knows what the hell it is anymore Elon Musk's Boring Company could be expanding to the East Coast Linkin Park's Mike Shinoda tweets about Chester Bennington's death There's a huge problem with voice chat and the Nintendo Switch Online app Ed Sheeran says he did not delete his Twitter account because of 'Game of Thrones' 'Stargate' returns with new digital series based on the early life of Catherine Langford New 'Game of Thrones' photos for Season 7 episode 2, 'Stormborn' Your PB&J is about to get a whole lot better with rosé jelly 'Words With Friends' might get a TV show. But...why? Not again: Hackers steal $32 million worth of Ethereum What you need to know about Bitcoin, Ethereum, and smart contracts Did Bran ruin everything in the most boring way possible? Grandpa devised the cutest emoji cheatsheet imaginable Are Amazon's prices too good to be true? The U.S. government wants to find out. This new AP course could drastically improve diversity in tech 'Game of Thrones' has brought winter to Comic
2.93s , 8223.890625 kb
Copyright © 2025 Powered by 【Beauty Salon Special Service 4】,Information Information Network